Maintaining a healthy and welcoming forum requires a solid moderation system that encourages good behavior while addressing rule violations fairly. A warning points system is an effective way to manage misconduct without resorting to immediate harsh punishments. Implementing this forum moderation tip can help you create a positive environment for your users by discouraging repeat offenses and giving users a chance to improve.
What Is a Warning Points System?
A warning points system assigns points to users who break community rules. These points accumulate over time, leading to increasing consequences based on severity. Instead of permanently banning users for minor infractions, this system provides a structured approach to rules violations.
The key advantages of a warning points system include:
- Transparency: Users understand the consequences of their actions.
- Fairness: Punishments are based on severity and repeated behavior.
- Second Chances: Users can improve without facing immediate bans.
Minor Violations
| Spamming | 1 point, Reminder about the rules |
| Off-topic posts | 1 point, Reminder about the rules |
| Posting duplicate content | 1 point, Reminder about the rules |
| Slightly inappropriate language | 1 point, Reminder about the rules |
Moderate Violations
| Mild trolling or baiting | 2, 3 day ban |
| Minor harassment | 2, 3 day ban |
| Disruptive behavior in threads (changing the direction of the conversation too much) | 2, 3 day ban |
| Repeated off-topic posts after being warned | 2, 3 day ban |
Serious Violations
| Offensive language or slurs | 4, 7 day ban |
| Ignoring direct moderation or prior warnings | 4, 7 day ban |
| Spamming links or excessive self-promotion | 4, 7 day ban |
| Aggressive trolling that disrupts community peace | 4, 7 day ban |
Severe Violations
| Harassment | 6, 30 day ban |
| Offensive language or slurs (Hate speech, racism, or bigotry) | 6, 30 day ban |
| Posting explicit or NSFW content | 6, 30 day ban |
Threatening A Permanent Ban
If a user has accumulated 6+ points multiple times, or continues to engage in severe violations after warnings, they could be given a final warning that a permanent ban may occur if they reoffend. We think that permanent bans should be rare and users should always be given ample time to improve their behavior. Temporary bans with varying lengths depending on the severity of the infraction have always worked well for us to give problem users distance from the site and time to consider their actions before they return. Before applying the temporary ban, the user should be given a clear and final warning about the consequences, stating they are at risk of being banned permanently if they break the rules again.
However, there are times when a permanent ban may need to be used. If the user reaches 10+ points or has an extreme rules violation, a permanent ban may be used. Before applying the temporary ban, the user should be given a clear and final warning about the consequences, stating they are at risk of being banned permanently if they break the rules again. Every community we’ve worked with is different and there is a lot of nuance to be considered when working with communities, regardless of size.
Points Expiration
Here’s another moderation tip: Warning points shouldn’t last forever. If a period of time has passed without any additional violations, users should be rewarded for their good behavior and have those points expire. We believe warning points should expire after 6 months. This gives users a chance to improve their behavior without carrying a permanent penalty and still gives us a good length of time to monitor their site activity.
Let’s Wrap It Up
A warning points system is an excellent way to balance fairness and enforcement in your forum. By allowing users to learn from mistakes while discouraging repeated violations, you create a space where discussions thrive without unnecessary hostility. If you’d like help implementing this system in your community, reach out and we’d be happy to help! Don’t forget to check out our other articles and guides on managing your online community.
The post Community Moderation Tips: Warning Points Model appeared first on Adjourn.